Showing posts with label US Federal Reserve. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US Federal Reserve. Show all posts

Friday, June 01, 2012

Understanding the basics of National Debt

A recent article in economic times caught my eye...it was about increasing levels of India's public debt. Considering that this, along with inflation, is quoted to be the primary reason of money flowing out of the country, I thought let me put a few points together to put this in a little more perspective for those who don't understand these terms well.

Consider this:

India's GDP is approximately USD 1.5 Trillion (that's USD 1,500,000,000,000)...almost equivalent to the monetary base of the US Federal Reserve (i.e. amount of money floating with the public in US + commercial bank reserves with the central bank). This amount is what all the products and services produced in India within 1 year are worth.

India's Public Debt, or total government debt, is approx. USD 636 bn, which comes to roughly 40% of the GDP. This is the amount the Indian government has raised to finance its projects, and the difference between its revenues (through taxes) and expenditure (salaries, infrastructure, etc.), also known as the fiscal deficit. Every year, some of this debt will come due (mature) and government will decide whether to take on more debt or not depending on its requirements from deficit. Also, every year, Indian government will need to pay interest on servicing this loan, pretty much similar to our EMIs. Any economy that's not growing at all, will have to service this interest burden by either printing more money, or by taking on more debt equivalent to the interest amount. In such a scenario, it becomes almost imperative for the countries to grow just to avoid the debt trap.

Just to put this in perspective, here is a list of some other countries where the public debt is at fairly high levels:
  • Japan - 200%
  • Greece - 144%
  • Iceland - 123%
  • Italy - 118%
  • Belgium - 102%
  • Singapore - 102%
  • Ireland - 98%
  • France - 83.5%
  • Portugal - 83.2%
  • UK - 76.5%
  • Germany - 75%
  • Brazil - 60%
  • US - 64%
US GDP is approx. USD 14.7 trillion, which puts their public debt at over USD 9 trillion....or nearly 6 times of India's GDP! The total amount that US would have to pay as interest just in 2011 is over approx. USD 3.5 trillion...and some people even say that by 2020, whatever US earns as revenue, the entire amount will go into paying interest on the debt ! An interesting website to look at for knowing and understanding these figures is the usdebtclock.org.

But the problem is not just with the US, the entire continent of North America has an average of 62% public debt, and a close second is Europe with an average public debt of around 56%. Asia, Africa, South America and Oceania regions all have an average under 45%.

From the look of it, everyone is in a worse situation than the other one, and unlike in EU, most others still have the flexibility to print their way out of their mess. US being the world's largest economy, is also dealing with far larger figures on every front - so a mere 0.1% increase in unemployment makes huge waves in the financial circuit.

As for India, the debt and inflation are high, and so is fiscal deficit at over 5.2% of GDP, but three major points supporting India are growth, demographics, and ability to print money. Moreover, a majority of the debt is payable internally, and terms and conditions with internal parties can be negotiated without bringing in IMF into account in the worst case of sovereign default.

Given this, to me, the fall in the markets, the flight (outwards) of the money, looks like a temporary phenomenon, which is probably also a very good (even last!) chance of buying the lower levels in the market. And as for Gold, till US is printing money, I wouldn't care much about its fall, its primary trend will remain up.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

How Fed pumps in money into the system

An interesting article in the NY Times explains it all - how US Federal Reserve pumps money into the system...basically, the grail of how Quantitative Easing works.

Take a look at how QE works here, explained in a simple way:

(click for a sharper image)

Basically, Fed prints money and deposits it in its own account (I know what you're thinking of right now...I wished the same ;)). This money is then used to buy back bonds sold by US Treasury to banks. The bank use this money for lending, both commercial and retail, through lower interest rates, which motivates people to take loans and spend it on either revenue / capital expenditure. This creates demand for people, products, services and takes the economy on a higher growth path.

The article gives a glimpse of how it all is actually executed by a few traders sitting in the Fed's office...and buying bonds from the 18 PDs (Primary Dealers - who have the sole authority to buy bonds from treasury in the first place).

So, by issuing QE I, Fed bought back bonds worth over $ 1 tn from these large banks / PDs, and with QE II, Fed is again buying back another $ 600 bn from them. All this money is supposed to go into the system as loans to companies and people like you and me...to build better products, to buy houses, etc. but is it actually happening?

Consider this really interesting article from The Telegraph, which talks about trap that America's have-nots are in. It talks about how high-end luxury stores like Cartier and Louis Vuitton US are witnessing strong growth over 50%, but bargain shops like best buy and Walmart are seeing a drop in sales !

It summarized the context of this post beautifully:

"Such is the blighted fruit of Federal Reserve policy. The Fed no longer even denies that the purpose of its latest blast of bond purchases, or QE2, is to drive up Wall Street, perhaps because it has so signally failed to achieve its other purpose of driving down borrowing costs."

It further goes on to say:

"Corporate America is in a V-shaped recovery,” said Robert Reich, a former labour secretary. “That’s great news for investors whose savings are mainly in stocks and bonds, and for executives and Wall Street traders. But most American workers are trapped in an L-shaped recovery."

I like that phrase - "L-shaped recovery"...personifies the current pain of American Middle-class...with its growing mortgages as interest rates grow, inability to get out of their investments in housing, unemployment hitting every 5th employable person, and even pensions at risk because of states inability to keep up with the payments.

And all that Fed does is to pump in more money into the system - very much like digging deeper in order to get out of the trench...all the best making it work Sammy.

Monday, January 10, 2011

Global Oulook for 2011

Here are a few questions that I posed in my post earlier. These are a part of the Global Outlook for 2011, some of the most important questions staring us in the face right now....from Euro to Gold, Currency wars to US recovery. Enjoy the ride...

  • Is Euro zone going to fall apart? Will Euro cease to exist as a currency?
Tough one to start with....the troubles in EU seem never-ending...its like the "Hydra of Lerna" (from Greek mythology)...a deadly serpent which had nine heads, and each time one head was cut-off, two more came up. Only this time, it all first started with Iceland instead of Greece. [Remember the good 'ol joke about Iceland's capital? It was arguably around 4 Euros !]

The troubles have since passed through Greece and Ireland, and looks set to suck-in Portugal, Italy and Spain sometime soon. And don't forget, its not that Iceland, Greece and Ireland are out of troubled waters just because they got handed over some nice bail-outs.

Unlike the US, since EU is woven with the same currency with different political leaderships, the more Euros that are printed and given out, the more the purchasing power of the other EU nations reduces (as it devalues their currency as well). People in countries that are better off, like Germany and France, don't like this Robin-hood story being played on them...(I think rightly so). But what choice do they have? If they don't bail-out these guys, their banks are going to take a big hit on the Iceland / Greek / Ireland bonds they hold...which is going to put them into trouble...creating a contagion effect.

Moreover, as per recent reports, German leadership, under pressure from the vote-bank, is getting tougher on such bail-outs. Reduced bail-outs with severe austerity-imposing conditions will not make things any better for the troubled countries.
So from the looks of it, EU has tough choices, and it'll have to do a tight-rope walk between keeping its vote-bank happy and letting the Euro go down. My guess is, it'll continue making and imposing tough choices on near-default nations, who'll have to abide by the rules, and manage their civil unrest internally. May be, just may be, to teach others a lesson, one of the countries just might be let out of the EU, possibly the worst & smallest one, which will also help shoring up Euro value and giving a moral boost to the general EU public.

Accordingly, Euro should continue to do badly, but abandoning Euro altogether is probably not an option. Euro should sustain for some more time.
  • Which countries in Euro-zone are getting into trouble next? Will anyone default?
Taking over from the previous question, Portugal, Italy and Spain should be next in line, possibly in that order. But to default either the country has to choose it or or they have to be made to default. My guess is, and its really just a guess, that probably Portugal should default, although i cant say due to which of the 2 reasons above...and probably Germany and France may even force Portugal out of the EU.

Again, like I said above, not doing it with Portugal will further emphasize the fact that individual country's leaderships are willing to sacrifice their people's financial health for the overall health of the EU...which not many people will like. Also, while Portugal is big, its not as big a problem as Italy / Spain...so letting it default will probably just cause tropical storms in the financial sectors and not a Default Tsunami. Such an action will also prove to people that their leadership cares first about them and then the general good of people who've spent & speculated mindlessly in the boom times.
  • How will the currency war be played out between US and China?
Include Euro here and what we get is a thriller of a race... to the bottom ! Let's try and understand what's happening here...as global demand for almost everything goes down, countries increasingly prefer a weaker domestic currency (e.g. 54 INR / USD is weaker than 45 INR / USD; 8 CNY / USD is weaker than 6.6 CNY / USD...and so on). This helps the countries compensate the lack of demand / growth with increased export value. Therefore, with say, 15% weaker currency, even a drop of 10% in exports will result in net realizations of +5% for the country.

So, to prop up their fledgling economies, all countries are trying hard to push their currencies down. China, under pressure from various groups and markets, has let their currency appreciate from nearly 8.3 CNY / USD to current levels of 6.62 CNY / USD...a strengthening of almost 25% ! And the US is still crying hoarse about Chinese currency's undervaluation...! Now, this is not to say whether Chinese currency is fairly valued or not, the point is, the amount of strength Chinese currency shows from here, that much growth is required in Chinese exports just to keep the value of exports same...and where is that growth going to come from? US, UK, EU, India, SE Asia, Australia? All have the same problem and are trying hard to keep their currencies weaker and fulfill all their domestic demand internally by putting more import restrictions in place.

My take on this is, its going to end up in favor of China ! Despite all its problems of unemployment, housing starts, foreclosures, states approaching bankruptcies and what have you, US is still the safest bet amongst the likes of Euro, Renminbi and Yen, can keep pumping in money to keep a semblance of sanity longer than most believe, and still amounts for a massive pie in the global consumption.Many states are nearing bankruptcies, but can pull along from an year's perspective.

China, on the other hand, is already struggling with inflation and poor domestic consumption growth at the same time...(consider reading my earlier post on Inflation in China and India). It has massive infrastructure just lying around waiting to be used, strengthening currency is further eroding wafer-thin margins from export oriented manufacturing units - further limiting the worker's pay rises. Although China is making amends to avoid a crash, in terms of diversifying into Gold, asking its trading partners to use CNY as base currency for trading, buying out debt from EU zone to help stabilize Euro, and investing big-time in agriculture to address the supply side issues in agriculture, my feeling is, its too small an effort too late in the day.

Also, given the expectations that demand from Japan is not going to be very encouraging, (consider my earlier post on Understanding China and Japan), commodities and manufacturing dependent China is far less likely to be able to avoid a crash...which might help it in at  least one way - it'll weaken its currency quite a bit. Such currency crisis at global levels have occurred before but this time around the difference is restrained geo-political efforts in containing it. Almost everyone is so deep in crap, that fending for themselves is top priority now.  There is no consensus on who to trust and which side to stand on. In times of global crisis, like these,  USD will appear a fairly decent haven, especially when compared to CNY, Eur and Yen.

  • Will the US Economy recover?
Fairly unlikely but considering the uncertain scenarios elsewhere in Japan, China, EU, Australia and SE Asia, I think it should do just OK this year...or rather "muddle through". US states will continue to have problems clearing their pension bills, the unemployment is really difficult to come down, the foreclosures are likely to maintain pace, and Fed is likely to give-in to a QE III if need be, to keep the rotting machinery lubricated for some more time. So its not that the problems in US are going to get solved any time soon, but I look at this as a Titanic sinking, due to its massive size, it'll take time sinking.

  • Are Gold and Silver the new proxies for currencies? Will countries start dealing in Gold and shun dollar completely?
While gold is widely accepted as a good alternative to any currency, world is not likely to move freely (stealthily, maybe) to a gold standard. This is primarily because large economies like Japan, China, EU countries, hold humongous amounts of US bonds...so if they show clear interest towards dealing in Gold, US Bond prices are going to crash...and so will the M2M value of all central banks' holdings. So right now, countries are stealthily diversifying their holdings into gold and other currencies (e.g. China, instead of buying gold from markets, which will be widely known and reported, is quietly buying gold mines worldwide, and marking down their potential reserves). 
 
However, this is a shift that will continue to take place, albeit slowly - like IMF has started accepting payments in Gold. So instead of seeing a massive move towards Gold as a reserve currency, we're fairly likely to see subtle shifts, which will also help in keeping the Gold prices up and rising for the year to come.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Markets, Currencies, Gold and Geopolitical Equations

Trust markets to save the surprise element for a well-drafted climax. The stage was all set for a thriller action-packed movie whose story was supposed to be something like this:

US Government reduced interest rates, encouraged borrowing, created asset bubbles, and made people believe that bubbles are here to stay...everyone and their grandmothers minted money where ever they put their investments...everyone's happy...then came crisis, 'something's gotta give' proponents were proved correct - and then...Lehman happened...all hell broke loose...Intermission !

US released approx. $ 1.7 tn of funds into the markets, bailed out "too big to fail" institutions, and things started improving...some jolts came from Europe's crisis pockets, but they too were managed by showing strength of confidence and trust in Euro and Euro-zone. But as time elapsed, people realized things were not improving...jobs were still getting lost...growth was still anemic, foreclosures were still setting newer records...and the US Government (better known as G'mint by now), was under pressure again. US G'mint has to seem to be doing "something" in the face of obvious debacle in mid-term elections.

US Federal reserve releases money into US's banking and financial system, thinking they'll be able to spur growth and depreciate their currency against others - giving them a double benefit (dollar depreciation helps US in improving exports, eases interest payments on debt)

Meanwhile, the economists and analysts, both independent and attached to large investment houses worldwide denounce the policy...(with yours humbly included in this crowd) and prophesy that dollar will depreciate against all currencies, all right, but US financial system will die a slow death, (ok there was a divide here with some calling for a deflation), and all other assets in all other markets will shoot up...(of course, no Top for Gold in sight)

And out comes the market, with the final verdict - the worst of both worlds - Euro crisis breaks-out first, US dollar appreciates (like Zero Hedge wrote in one of his posts - People see it as a Bullish sign for dollar that US will default Later than Europe !). Markets worldwide tank...China raises its interest rates in anticipation of free dollars flowing in...Euro loses value, all commodities go down, markets tumble, even Gold tanks...The End !

I know that its still too early in the day to talk about the "outcome". We're still quite far away from playing out the entire game. On these lines IceCap Asset Management has come up with an excellent (and funnily sarcastic) view of the overall game-plan (HT: Zero Hedge)...(you can see the Nov 2010 report from Icecap here). A small preview of what's in this report:

With the QE2 announcement now out of the way, Mr. Bernanke’s game plan is as follows:
  1. Lower interest rates for "everybody" and "everything"
  2. Stocks & Bonds will then increase in value making "everybody" and "everything" feel wealthier
  3. "Everybody" will then start to buy "everything"
  4. Pray that the price of "everything" doesn’t increase too much and therefore cause "everybody" not to buy "everything"
  5. If steps 1 to 4 are successful, businesses will begin to create jobs for "everybody" because they will once again be buying "everything"
  6. Ignore the housing market problem
  7. Ignore the debt problem
  8. Ignore the effect of numbers 6 & 7 on the banks
  9. Pray that foreigners continue to buy newly issued American debt
The report is a good read...please do take time out to go through it.

The point here is, the crisis in Europe has not gone away...and again predictions of who's next (after Ireland) have started pouring in...neither has US taken the right step by taking on more debt to get out of their debt trap, and they will pay for it sometime or the other...there is an increased coordinated activity globally on debasing dollar as the world's reserve currency, on acquiring Gold by central bankers - either through market or stealthily through un-announced mines acquisitions...the banks are on the edge again, with over 900 banks closing down in US alone in the last year or two, (and expectations from European banks are no better)

The way it is, (HT: John Mauldin - for giving this perspective) its not really about the markets / asset bubbles per se, there is a larger game at play here - that of Confidence and Trust. Confidence on Governments, on Growth, on policies and policy changes...Trust between banks and FIs, between countries, between two counterparties exchanging commodities for Dollars. At a really broad level, its a Geopolitical failure...with Governments not taking enough / correct steps, thinking of their economy as mutually exclusive from that of trading partners and global economy... In the past as well, many recessions were due to lack of confidence and a complete break-down of trust...even the crisis that started in 2008, was triggered when banks stopped trusting each other with their money...that's when the financial juggernaut stopped rolling, and government pushed in money thinking it'll lubricate the system and things will be smooth again...

Like Soros said recently, the "new world order" is emerging...lets hope once the game is played out completely, we'll make a fresh start with Confidence and Trust.

Saturday, November 13, 2010

Rumblings of Markets bumbling, tumbling & crumbling

I don't know whats' scarier, that so much has happened to the markets in just a couple of days OR that this happens so frequently. This post looks like its gonna be a long one...so I'll start with listing down the dots, and then spend some time connecting them...followed by some philosophical discussion ;). Stay with me on this one, for its gonna have some links to very good documents and other blog-posts as well.

Some of my select picks among many data points:
  • China Market tumble 5% on Interest Rate Increase:
The People's Bank of China increased its lending interest rates by 25 basis points (0.25%) to 5.56% - its first increase since 2007. The central bank is expected to follow suit this week-end or early next week. This is apparently being done to rein in inflation which is a major cause of concern in China. China has obviously timed it to offset dollars flowing in from the QE II release, and there are talks of another rate increase before the end of this year. Markets see this as a dampener to growth, and future investments in the markets so the markets tanked over 5%, its single biggest loss since Aug 2009. A snippet of what went on in the Chinese markets on 12th Nov (courtesy: Bloomberg)



  • Commodity Markets tumble: 
Crude Oil, Sugar, Soybeans, Corn fell sharply on news of interest rate hike from China. The markets are expecting a slow-down in demand of various commodities due to increase in interest rates (interest rates are usually increased to rein in inflation, as people save more (to earn more interest) and spend less - thus this kind of move takes away free-money from the system, clamping demand and thus reducing inflation). If you would like to read more about this, read it on Mish's blog - here. As per LA Times, sugar fell 11%, gold 2.7%, copper 3.2%, and soybeans 5%.

  • Ireland's debt crisis spooks investors:
The PIGS (Portugal, Ireland, Greece and Spain) are back in news. Apparently, investors are getting worried about Ireland's ability to repay its debt, and mirroring this sentiment are the bond markets worldwide, which sent the Irish bonds prices tumbling resulting in difference in yields between the Ireland and German 5-year bonds to a record 6.6% (yields on bonds increase when bond prices go down - which they do in such times when sovereign rating suffers (country doesn't seem to have money to repay its debt) or if prospects of interest rates reduction in future are higher - more on this in some other post). But EU was quick to come out with some reassurances (here - a post by Calculated Risk) which calmed the markets down to some extent. Read a good article on this from WSJ here. 
However, this news did cause quite some worry to global investors who pulled out their money from equity and commodity markets - not really because Ireland is a large economy but due primarily to the fear of contagion effect, i.e. If Ireland defaults, Portugal and Greece might get in a worse condition than they are now (since they hold substantial amounts of bonds from Ireland) and if they too default, so will Spain, and then so will France and Germany - the two biggest countries in the EU...and then down goes Euro - triggering a global currency crisis. (I know it seems like a doom's day scenario, but if markets are taking these thoughts into consideration, its scary to sense how close we might be to this turning into a reality). [Another good post for further reading by Mish here]

  • Euro falls against Dollar, then pulls back some:
Spooked by the Ireland debt crisis, the Euro fell sharply against dollar but recovered a bit after the regulators made some reassuring statements. If the focus again moves towards evaluating the sustainability of the Euro-zone as a region, and Euro as a sustainable currency, dollar may not fall against other currencies as was widely believed post QE II (that's a release of USD 600 billion by US Federal Reserve into the banking and financial system to spur markets and growth).

Now, the essence of the above picks is that there is no single path post QE II - this path was thought to be something like this:

Fed Releases Money (QE II - USD 600 bn) ----> US doesn't have fundamental to absorb this cash ----> Money finds its way into other markets (China, India, Brazil, Russia, Korea, Singapore, etc.) and other asset classes (real estate, commodities) (as a result of all this dollar selling and buying of local currencies, the latter goes up against the former) ----> Markets worldwide move up, so does Gold ----> Inflation (as imported by US) increases in world markets ---->US starts exporting more to feed that growth (as with depreciated dollar, US goods become cheaper; also, US interest payments (huge now, even bigger in future with a strong dollar) feel lighter for the government)----> US economy recovers due to jobs returning, fueling demand ----> World markets increase interest rates to rein inflation ----> Markets tank ----> Dollar moves out ----> Local Currency appreciates ---> Exports pick up ----> Economy picks up....
Now, that's more or less the holy grail of the markets, and economics.

What has instead happened (from the little data unraveled so far), is that the cycle has skipped some middle steps ...

Fed Releases Money (QE II - USD 600 bn) ----> Fearing inflation and asset bubbles, China increases interest rates to rein potential / future inflation (a precautionary measure)----> Markets tank ----> ....???

Just like life, markets too are in a hurry to catch up with the end...but all said, this puts a big question mark over how things are going to unravel post QE II. An excellent post by Mish (again) on this here.

And with this, the age-old questions are here to haunt us again - Is this the end of the beginning or the beginning of the end? Have we topped out on markets? On Gold? Should we completely get out? But stay in cash ? Which Currency?

My take is, (atleast for Indian markets) hang-on...we have good supports coming up a little further down from here...domestic demand is still intact...asset bubbles (real estate, indices) aren't of enormous proportions as in other countries...Inflation is a concern but regulator is taking measures occasionally to rein it in, Gold - well, a good hedge for its strong fundamental factors is a possible depreciation of dollar against INR. We'll have to be cautious, alert, nimble...as things pan out better in the open.

Till now, the normal approach was seen as US Fed release money ---> US markets improve ----> US Economy recovers....(as expected by the US Fed)...

And the contrarian approach was that this will not happen....instead the dollar will depreciate, US will not benefit from releasing money, other countries will...and so on.

But with the developments in the markets during the last couple of days, the contrarian approach really seems that Gold will go down, emerging markets will go down, dollar will appreciate against most other currencies, etc. 

At the end of it, the funny thing with taking a contrarian approach is, if you're taking a contrarian approach without knowing how many contrarians are there in the market, and if there are too many contrarians in the market, which one is the contrarian approach, really? 

Think about it...I will...!
Leaving you with some food for your thoughts...

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Currency Crisis - Impending Regulatory Restrictions

Ok, Fed's fed-up with no real progress on the growth since the last QE (Quantitative Easing) of nearly a trillion dollars - so its' decided to pump in another 0.6 trn more into the system - primarily for buying debt of nearly insolvent organizations...not good - say many central bankers.


I was reading this excellent article through Mish, (you can read full text here). It points out that some countries, including South-Korea, China (incl. HK), and Brazil have already indicated in no unclear terms that they're deeply concerned about a lot of QEII money flowing into their currency and upsetting the finely balanced currency system (read appreciating local currency, lower exports, expanding trade deficit, coupled with lobbyists getting upset, and governments not seeming in control of the economy). So they've indicated a slew of measure to be put in place to ensure that the money doesn't flow-in too easily.


That said, the Golden Indian regulatory bird is yet to flutter its wings...and I don't think its sleeping...so I do expect some tightening in FDI policies sometime soon...timing is of essence here - considering a battery of PSU FPOs and IPOs lined up. If the markets get a whiff of such measures, its gonna tank - taking disinvestment targets out of reach for this financial year at least.


So Stay tuned...and stay nimble.